Google
has suffered a setback in its plans to be the dominant global news aggregating
service following a court ruling that bars it from using content from Belgian
news sites.
The action was brought without Google being present in court, and appears to
have taken the search company by surprise.
"Google only found out about this lawsuit and the court's decision on Friday,
almost two weeks after the actual hearing, and as a result we were not able to
make our case directly to the judge," said D J Collins, Google's head of
corporate communications for UK, Ireland and Benelux.
The Belgian court ruled that headlines and web links to stories on Belgian
press websites were copyrighted and that Google would have to pay a €1m daily
fine until the content was removed.
Google confirmed that it was complying with the order to remove the Belgian
newspapers represented at the trial from all of its news sites.
The case was brought by copyright organisation Copiepress on behalf of the
Belgian press, and represented titles such as
Le Soir,
La
Derniére Heure and
La
Libre Belgique.
Collins has insisted that the court case was unnecessary and that Google
would have removed the publications voluntarily if it had been asked to do so.
"Google has a clear policy of respecting the wishes of content owners," he
explained.
"If a newspaper does not want to be part of
Google
News we remove its content from our index. All they have to do is ask. There
is no need for legal action and all the associated costs."
Collins pointed out that Google is able to reproduce headlines under national
and international copyright law, and that all the company does is send traffic
to publishers' websites.
"We have far more publishers talking to us about being included in the index
than about being removed, and one national newspaper within Europe gets up to a
quarter of its website traffic from Google News," he said.
The court ruling took place on 5 September but the details have only just
come to light.
A previous case brought by
Agence
France-Presse prompted Google to remove all of that company's content from
its sites.
Google has also recently run into trouble over its
book publishing
service, which offers free downloads.
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article