Microsoft
The European Commission has accused Microsoft of failing to adhere to a 2004 antitrust settlement

Microsoft under fire from the EU again

Commission claims royalty prices are too high

Written by Shaun Nichols in California

Microsoft has once again found itself in danger of running foul of the European Union

The European Commission has accused the company of not adhering to the terms of a 2004 antitrust settlement.  

The charges stem from a term in the 2004 ruling dictating that Microsoft must offer competing server makers access to interoperability code which would allow the servers to work with Windows-powered notebooks and PCs.

The 2004 case ended up costing Microsoft close to €500m, and European Commission spokesman Jonathan Todd told reporters in Brussels that the company could incur fines of hundreds of millions of euros for this latest transgression.

Microsoft contended that it had a right to charge fees to companies wishing to use the interoperability technology, which contains patented and unpatented technologies.

The company proposed that for a fee, vendors could have access to the interoperability components without having to pay a licensing charge for the patents.

The EU's view, however, was that there was little innovative technology worth charging for.

"Microsoft has agreed that the main basis for pricing should be whether its protocols are innovative. The Commission's current view is that there is no significant innovation in these protocols," said competition commissioner Neelie Kroes.

The Commission claims that a review of patented and unpatented technologies that comprise the interoperability software found only four minor components that "represent a limited degree of information".

Microsoft senior vice president and general counsel Brad Smith blasted the Commission's decision in a written response.

"The proposed findings suggest that unless our intellectual property is innovative and patentable, it has to be made available royalty free," he said.

"That has never been the standard for software or other intellectual property and it misstates the test agreed to by the Commission and Microsoft in 2005.

"We believe we have been fair in setting proposed protocol prices, and an analysis by PricewaterhouseCoopers found that our proposed prices were at least 30 per cent below the market rate for comparable technology." 

The Commission has given Microsoft four weeks to respond.

Tags:

Further reading

Related articles

Microsoft plays nice with the EU

General counsel Brad Smith vows to bend over backwards   More...

Microsoft's EU patent pledge incompatible with GPL

Patent pledge will not transfer to downstream users   More...

EU forces Microsoft to cage open source patent dogs

Redmond forced to provide free, irrevokable patent pledge to non-commercial open source   More...

Microsoft ends European antitrust appeal

Redmond will comply fully with the court's decision   More...

Do you agree?

Advertisement

Job of the week

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Hiring now on ComputingCareers:

Related IT jobs

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Advertisement

Watch

04 Jul 2008

5.51 MBPodcast Special: Views from the Valley More...

03 Jul 2008

3.46 MBGreen grid computing, Trojans stop play and location-based services More...

02 Jul 2008

3.2 MBOnline TV, SME security and flexible laptops More...

Poll

EUROPEAN E-COMMERCE

EUROPEAN E-COMMERCE

Are you happy making an online purchase from another European country?

Previous poll results

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Spotlight

Online pornography

US rebate cheques spent on porn

Economic stimulus package works wonders   More...

Louis Vuitton

UK online fake goods market worth £800m

Legal experts warn of dramatic rise in 'e-fencing'   More...

Advertisement

Fibre-optics

New fibre-optic connections overtake cable

Broadband first-timers choosing fibre where possible   More...

Stars and Stripes

Cyber-crooks celebrate Independence Day

Security firms warn users to take extra care   More...

Advertisement