image: sid meiers railroads!
A good simulation game but not much for the more experienced gamer

Review: Sid Meier's Railroads! game

Ride the rails from your armchair

Written by Anthony Dhanendran

Larger Image

Advertisement

There has long been only one option for those of us who enjoy games of economic warfare rather than guns and bombs, and that is Railroad Tycoon. However, the Tycoon series’ creator, Sid Meier, who’s no longer involved with the title, has now released his own update to the game he invented over a decade ago.

Anyone who has played the latest Railroad Tycoon game, version three, will find Railroads! instantly familiar. The same old building blocks are all there, and the aim is much the same too.

Players lay down track, build stations, and carry passengers, mail and cargo between towns and cities. As the game progresses, not only do new engines become available, but the landscape is affected by how you play – settlements that receive heavy traffic grow into towns, and then into giant cities. By the end of a game, it’s hard to imagine that it all started with a single train and a pair of station buildings.

The competitive element comes from the fact that other players are fighting over the same territory. As with Railroad Tycoon, these can be computer-generated figures, or humans playing over the internet.

The game looks great – it takes full advantage of the latest graphics technology, and that means that a reasonably fast PC is required to get the most out of it. That said, we managed to get a very playable game running on our test PC, which is around 18 months old.

Gameplay is easier than in the most recent Tycoon game – the economic aspect has been simplified, making it much easier for newcomers and younger players to pick up the game and get building. However, anyone used to shuffling goods around the map to get them in just the right place, and building the right units in the right place, might find Railroads a little too simple.

There were a few glitches in which the program stopped responding or crashed, but we put that down to this being an early version. Expect to see a downloadable fix released by the game's makers to solve this.

While Railroads! is a good attempt to make the game more playable, it could be too simple for some people. Then again, as a fun way of getting younger players interested in the basics of economics, it works well.

Also consider:
Ship Simulator
Take to the waves in a virtual ship

Civilization 4
If world domination has always been one of your ambitions, you won't be able to resist Civilization 4

All simulation game reviews

Tags:

Product overview

  • Price: £30
  • Manufacturer: 2K Games
  • Specifications:

Best prices

Ratings

  • Overall rating: 3
  • Features: n/a
  • Performance rating: n/a
  • Value for money: n/a
  • Average user rating:
Rate this product

Verdict

Good points

  • Excellent graphics
  • Internet multiplayer

Bad points

  • May be too basic for old hands
  • Some stability problems

Overall Sid Meier's Railroads is a good update but could alienate gamers familiar with railroad games

See also:

Advertisements

Do you agree?

Most commented stories

IT white papers

Search vnunet IThound

Top categories

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Poll

INTERNET EXPLORER 8

INTERNET EXPLORER 8

Are you intending to download Internet Explorer 8 when it becomes available?

Previous poll results

Spotlight

LogMeIn Rescue+Mobile

BlackBerry gets LogMeIn remote support

Rescue+Mobile lets a support technician take control of the handset   More...

Dell manufacturing plant

Dell planning factory closures to cut costs

Report claims that PC maker is looking to sell off...  More...

Google Chrome

More growing pains for Chrome

Google wrestles with licensing and security problems   More...

Smartphone

US takes 3G crown from Europe

Americans finally catch up with Europeans in adoption of 3G   More...

Primary Navigation