German court grants injunction against Fortinet for allegedly violating GPL
German court grants injunction against Fortinet for allegedly violating GPL

Fortinet in court for hiding Linux in its code

Security vendor accused of GPL violation and trying to cover its tracks

Written by Tom Sanders in California

A German court has granted a preliminary injunction against security firm Fortinet for allegedly violating the general public licence (GPL) and hiding Linux in its code.

The ruling could prevent the security appliance vendor from further distributing its products until it complies with the open source licence.

Fortinet was accused of using cryptographic techniques to conceal the presence of Linux code in its FortiGate and FortiWifi products, as well as not releasing its source code under the terms of the GPL.

The company's use of Linux was deemed by the court to be in violation of the GPL under which Linux is distributed.

The licence allows for the reuse of the code, but requires that developers grant public access to all the source code and provide a copy of the full licence text.

The case was filed in Germany against Fortinet UK Ltd, the UK subsidiary of Fortinet Inc, by Harald Welte, a Linux developer who also runs the gpl-violations.org website.

The site aims to raise public awareness about past and present GPL violations, and has resolved 30 such cases in the past months.

"This violation by Fortinet is especially egregious since the vendor not only violated the GPL, but actively tried to hide that violation," Welte claimed.

Fortinet said in a statement to vnunet.com that the company has been working to resolve the issue outside court.

"Fortinet is surprised that Mr Welte pursued a preliminary injunction against Fortinet in Germany and believes that this is an unnecessary action," said the statement.

But Welte insisted that obtaining the injunction was a necessary step in persuading Fortinet to take the issue seriously, and had ended negotiations about a settlement.

"Fortinet apparently did not want to believe that this is a serious issue," Welte wrote in his blog.

With the rise of open source software in the enterprise, companies increasingly run the risk of violating open source or commercial software licences by mixing internally developed code with software that is governed by the GPL or other open source licence.

Tags:

Further reading

Novell claims 'richest ever' Linux distro

SuSE Linux Pro 9.3 aimed at advanced users and newbies   More...

Fears grow over 'unworkable' GPL

Fortinet case 'good news for Microsoft', claims analyst   More...

Open source licensing minefield looms

Proprietary software and open source don't mix well, warn legal experts   More...

Open source

Linux is becoming the operating system of choice for an increasing number of corporates, and even the mighty Microsoft is acknowledging the threat ...   More...

Related articles

GPL challenged in US court

Developers ask judge to enforce open source licence against device maker   More...

US legal case tests GPL's mettle

Is the open source licence a business contract or a copyright notice?   More...

Ebay receives stay of execution in one-click patent spat

Judge denies injunction, upholds ruling   More...

FTC lowers the curtain on Movieland spat

Site agrees to pay $500,000 to settle pop-up case   More...

Do you agree?

Advertisement

Job of the week

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Hiring now on ComputingCareers:

Related IT jobs

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Advertisement

Watch

24 Jul 2008

3.68 MBSpammer jailed, Esquire e-cover, and network passwords More...

23 Jul 2008

2.99 MBSmall time security, official 'spying' requests and a spammer jail break More...

22 Jul 2008

3.22 MBSat-nav crashes, open source security and female gamers More...

Poll

EUROPEAN E-COMMERCE

EUROPEAN E-COMMERCE

Are you happy making an online purchase from another European country?

Previous poll results

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Spotlight

Credit card transaction

Credit card fraud rampant in the UK

Attempted frauds go unreported and ignored, analysts claim   More...

Intel

Intel rolls out new embedded line-up

System-on-a-chip offerings promise footprint and power saving   More...

Advertisement

Network cables

Tech giants collaborate on wireless HD

Another attempt at cable-free transmission in the home   More...

iPhone fever fills AT&T coffers

US provider cashes in on Apple smartphone   More...

Advertisement