Sometimes, it seems, you can’t move for gadgets designed to let you share
content on your home network, with streamers, network-attached storage (Nas)
appliances and even mobile phones boasting that they’ll let us access our music,
data and movies any time, anywhere.
The harsh reality is somewhat different. There’s a wealth of different
standards involved, and even when you have two devices that have the same logos,
there’s no real guarantee that they’ll do what you want.
Take a network with a couple of UPnP (Universal Plug and Play) media players,
for example, the
Pinnacle
Soundbridge, and the
Helios
X5000, plus a Mac with iTunes, a Nas server with UPnP, and a
Nokia
N95 phone, which also boasts UPnP support. Both the Soundbridge and the X5000
can play back music from the Nas server. They can browse music on the N95 too,
if it’s set up to share it on the home network.
But they can’t browse the iTunes library on the Mac, unless the
Firefly
server software is added. And the Nokia phone can browse the network to see
files on the Nas device, or the Firefly music server – but it can’t actually
play anything from them. It can, however, send a stream to be played on the
Soundbridge, even allowing you to use the phone’s volume control to change the
level on the Soundbridge.
But it can’t do the same trick with the X5000. And all that’s before we’ve
added a few more so-called standards into the mix.
Alphabet soup
Standards are supposed to make life easier; and in some areas they do – buy a
bit of wireless kit with the
Wifi
logo on it, that has an 802.11g sticker, and it’ll connect to any Wifi network
with the same standard.
The theory behind UPnP media devices is the same – but just as wireless
users can sometimes find that it’s the details, such as encryption support, that
stop two supposedly compatible devices from working perfectly together, so the
world of home networking is full of potential pitfalls. So, what standards are
you likely to come across in your quest for a networked digital home, and what
do they all mean?
In this article, we’ll concentrate on the area of home entertainment and
media, and related systems that work with them – we won’t go into home
automation, for example. When it comes to devices that serve up or play back
content, UPnP and DLNA are acronyms you’re going to hear a lot about.
Rather than being specifically about media, UPnP is a way for devices to
configure themselves automatically (or be configured by another application) on
your network; it even allows, for example, for a gadget to request that your
router open specific firewall ports.
But it’s also important in terms of home media because one part of it –
UPnP AV – defines types of devices, such as media servers, media controllers
and media ‘renderers’ – playback devices – and how they discover each other
on the network. As we saw in our example right at the start though, that’s not
necessarily enough to make sure everything works together.
Although UPnP AV goes far enough to ensure that, in our example, we could
send music from our N95 to a Soundbridge music player, there are still gaps. And
it’s those gaps that
DLNA
– Digital Living Network Alliance – bridges.
If you are shopping for home media equipment at the moment, and want to be
sure of the best compatibility, it’s probably the DLNA-certified logo that you
should be watching out for. You will even see it on PCs and laptops these days,
so it’s not just for ‘brown’ goods.
A DLNA-certified product has to include UPnP support, which takes care of
devices being able to find each other on the network, but in addition, it
specifies certain file formats that need to be supported too, and that if a
device is trying to send information to another one that doesn’t understand the
format, it will transcode it.
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article