Picture of Nikkai Barebone Twin Tuner Freeview DTR
The Barebones requires a hard disk and the noise might just put buyers off

Review: Nikkai Barebone Twin Tuner Freeview DTR digital video recorder

A do-it-yourself way to record digital TV

Written by Tom Royal

Larger Image

Digital video recorders, or DVRs, have recently made the move from expensive luxury products to affordable devices that are well under £100.

Nikkai has come up with a new and rather unusual version, though: this is a PVR that you have to finish yourself.

The name Barebone might remind some of the fiddly process of putting together many small form factor PCs, but in fact this recorder is a cinch to assemble.

After opening the access hatch, it’s simply a case of screwing a 3.5in IDE hard disk into place, connecting two cables and then closing the case.

After that, simply plug in your aerial, along with the rather strange external jumper that links the two TV tuners, and you’re ready to record.

The on-screen menus aren’t particularly pretty and the remote control is small and fiddly, but it does work reasonably well.

We managed to quickly pull up the electronic programme guide (EPG), choose a show to watch then set another to record.

The interface isn’t anywhere near as slick as that of Sky+, for example, but it will suffice for occasional TV viewers.

There are, however, two significant problems with this device. The first is noise: many desktop hard disks are noisy, and its slim case does little to dampen this.

When not in standby mode, the hard disk is always spinning, even if it’s not recording at the time. We also found that the constant high-pitched hum of our hard disk was enough to put us off watching TV. If you want to use it in the living room, you’ll need to carefully select a quiet hard disk.

What’s more, it’s not particularly good value. By the time you’ve added a hard disk you might as well simply take the easy route and buy Thompson’s Top-Up-TV Plus recorder for around £90.

Product overview

  • Price: £59.99
  • Manufacturer: Maplin 0870 429 6000
  • Specifications: Requires a 3.5in IDE hard disk (up to 500GB) • Two digital tuners • Seven-day EPG • Two Scart outputs • Composite and S-video outputs • Phono and coaxial S/PDIF audio outputs

Best prices

Ratings

  • Overall rating: 3
  • Features: 4
  • Performance rating: 3
  • Value for money: 3
  • Average user rating:

Verdict

Pros: Easy to assemble; works reasonably well
Cons: Noisy; not necessarily cheaper than a pre-assembled DVR
Overall: Will work acceptably well if you choose a quiet hard disk, but you might as well pick up a ready-made PVR and save the trouble

See also:

Maplin recorder

Review: Maplin Barebone Twin Tuner Freeview DTR

Digital TV? Do it yourself   More...

image: Linksys DMA2200

Review: Linksys DMA2200 media streaming device

A media streamer with a great interface, but it demands Media Center   More...

Advertisiements

Do you agree?

Advertisement

IThound

Search white papers

Top categories

Advertisement

Poll

HOME WORKING

HOME WORKING

Do you let any or all of your employees work from home?

Previous poll results

Spotlight

OLPC

OLPC to ship with Windows XP

Microsoft teams up with One Laptop per Child project   More...

The Sims

The Sims goes flat-pack with Ikea

Virtual world gets Swedish wood   More...

Advertisement

Microsoft-Yahoo

Yahoo board fights back at Icahn

Investor accused of 'significant misunderstanding' in Microsoft saga   More...

MySpace

Woman charged over MySpace suicide

Lori Drew indicted on federal charges   More...

Advertisement