Business review: Smoothwall Corporate Guardian 5 content filtering
Effective content filtering that’s easy to set up

Review: Smoothwall Corporate Guardian 5 content filtering

Effective content filtering that’s easy to set up

Written by Alan Stevens

Larger Image

Smoothwall Corporate Guardian is a web access and content filtering solution, implemented in software and designed to protect networks with an existing firewall.

However, rather than simply filter URLs and check against blacklists, the software also uses a technology called Dynamic Content Analysis (DCA) to categorise content on-the-fly.

Advertisement

As such, it doesn’t just block objectionable material but can also screen out viruses, spyware and other malicious code.

Getting started is a doddle with no software dependencies as the supplied CD contains everything required, including a security-hardened Linux operating system.

All you have to do is pop the disc into a suitable PC, boot it up and answer a few network questions. The hard disk is then wiped clean and the new Linux OS and Smoothwall software installed.

Alternatively, you can do as we did to test the product and install Corporate Guardian on a virtual machine hosted on a VMWare, or other virtual server.

Once installed remote browser-based management is the order of the day with a fairly intuitive, if busy, interface to be mastered. And it’s worth noting that there’s quite a bit to do if you want to take advantage of all that Smoothwall software has to offer. Plus, you may also have to make client changes.

Two modes of operation are supported with so-called transparent mode, where the Smoothwall server simply becomes the default internet gateway, the easiest option calling only for a couple of DHCP tweaks.

However, to take advantage of authentication and other advanced features it’s better to reconfigure client browsers to use Corporate Guardian as a web proxy, something you can do with a script if many users are involved.

We took the proxy route and by following the quick-start guide had a working web proxy blocking access to adult, gambling and a range of other sites in about 10 minutes.

We were then able to assign the blocking rules to specific groups, authenticating users and controlling access via their network logon. This option requires an LDAP (Lightweight Directory Access Protocol) server, such as Active Directory, although authentication against a local user list is also supported.

We also found customising the message displayed when content is blocked to be quite easy and were impressed by the comprehensive logging and reporting facilities, further enhanced in version 5.0 with a clutch of new reports and support for Crystal Reports.

Also new in the 5.0 release are controls to screen out active code, such as Java and ActiveX applets, and scan for viruses, using either a built-in ClamAV engine or other ICAP-compatible scanner.

Time-based controls have also been added, plus rules to manage HTTPS access to, for example, block Skype and phishing sites that use this protocol, as well as SSL proxy sites designed to bypass web filters.

On the downside we encountered a few problems when testing Corporate Guardian, most of which were quickly resolved by changing our rule settings.

However, if the software has one weak point it’s the number of options available. As we found, it’s easy to get things wrong and either block access to the wrong people or allow unfettered access to those who shouldn’t have it.

That aside, once you get to grips with it the Smoothwall software works well. Plus you don’t need expensive hardware to host it which, with affordable licensing, will appeal to small businesses looking to control what users can see and do on the web.

Tags:

Product overview

  • Price: £400
  • Manufacturer: Smoothwall
  • Specifications: Minimum 1GHz processor (2.8GHz Pentium 4 or AMD Athlon recommended for more than 1,000 users)

Best prices

Ratings

  • Overall rating: 3
  • Features: 4
  • Performance rating: n/a
  • Value for money: 3
  • Average user rating:
Rate this product

Verdict

Pros: Easy to install with minimal hardware requirements; anti-virus and active content screening; time-based access controls; extensive reporting; optional transparent mode
Cons: Busy management interface; client browser changes needed for full functionality
Overall: A little over-complex in places, but an effective web-filtering package priced to appeal to the small business

See also:

Advertisements

Do you agree?

IT white papers

Search vnunet IThound

Top categories

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Poll

Google Android

Google Android

Are you intending to try out a Google Android mobile phone?

Previous poll results

Spotlight

MoD building

Latest data breach leads MPs to demand culture change

MoD admits to losing a hard drive containing up to...  More...

Online shopping

E-retailers urged to prepare for Christmas

Credit crunch sending shoppers online for cheaper presents   More...

Mobile phone

Emerging markets drive mobile growth

Mobile penetration rates expected to reach 95 per cent by...  More...

Digital information

Poor data classification costing companies dear

Millions wasted on searching through clutter, says analyst   More...

Primary Navigation