The US Patent Office has invalidated a patent at the centre of a dispute between RIM and NTP
The Patent Office ruling leaves only one of the disputed NTP patents in place

RIM scores BlackBerry patent victory

US Patent Office invalidates second NTP patent

Written by Tom Sanders in California

The US Patent and Trademark Office has invalidated a patent at the centre of a prolonged legal battle between BlackBerry maker Research in Motion and patent-holding company NTP. 

A jury found in 2002 that RIM infringed on NTP-owned patents that cover an email system on its BlackBerry mobile devices.

Appeals were thrown out and settlement talks failed. NTP ended up seeking an injunction against RIM that would force the vendor to shut down its service in North America.

Wednesday's rejection was based in part on information that had not been considered in the 2002 trial.

The Patent Office ruling leaves only one of the disputed NTP patents in place. The remaining patent has already been rejected twice and a final ruling is expected soon.

NTP still has the opportunity to appeal against the decision and has indicated in the past that it plans to do so. The overall process is expected to be dragged out for years.

RIM said in a statement that it was confident that the invalidation would withstand the appeal process.

While the invalidation is an important victory for RIM, the two firms are still scheduled to appear before a judge this Friday.

The judge is expected to rule on NTP's demand for an injunction against RIM that would force the vendor to discontinue its service in North America.

RIM unveiled a contingency plan earlier this month which it claims will allow the company to continue operating if the judge rules in NTP's favour. But analysts have questioned the stability and feasibility of the workaround.

Tags:

Further reading

RIM unveils BlackBerry patent workaround

'US mode' avoids technology covered by disputed NTP patent   More...

Analysts question BlackBerry patent workaround

Battle far from over, report warns   More...

RIM offers last minute NTP patent deal

Fourteen days left before dispute comes to court   More...

Patent Office takes second look at JPEG

Image compression patent could be invalid due to prior art   More...

Related articles

NTP sues several US wireless firms

Latest patent battle seeks royalty payments for email infringements   More...

Ebay receives stay of execution in one-click patent spat

Judge denies injunction, upholds ruling   More...

Real wins patent victory

Friskit's $70m lawsuit fails   More...

MPAA 'does not need' proof of piracy

Too difficult to obtain, says attorney   More...

Do you agree?

Advertisement

Job of the week

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Hiring now on ComputingCareers:

Related IT jobs

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Advertisement

Watch

23 Jul 2008

2.99 MBSmall time security, official 'spying' requests and a spammer jail break More...

22 Jul 2008

3.22 MBSat-nav crashes, open source security and female gamers More...

21 Jul 2008

3.12 MBGlobal internet reach, online spending and the space race More...

Poll

EUROPEAN E-COMMERCE

EUROPEAN E-COMMERCE

Are you happy making an online purchase from another European country?

Previous poll results

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Spotlight

Security

Major DNS flaw revealed

Experts sound alarms over early disclosure   More...

Nintendo DS

Dodgy Chinese Nintendo chargers recalled

Experience could shock some users   More...

Advertisement

Houses of Parliament

Official 'spying' requests top 500,000

Information includes web records and itemised phone bills   More...

Hacking

Small firms naïve about security

SMBs remain prone to attack, says study   More...

Advertisement