Government porn bill faces Backlash

Stiff opposition to ban on BDSM images

Written by Iain Thomson

The UK government is facing calls to drop its proposed ban on pornography featuring bondage and sadomasochism (BDSM).

New proposals contained in the Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill would make it a crime to view any image classed as "extreme".

This would include "an act which results in or appears to result (or be likely to result) in serious injury to a person's anus, breasts or genitals".

The new proposals were inspired by the murder of special needs teacher Jane Longhurst by Graham Coutts, who was a regular viewer of such images.

Longhurst's former partner, Malcolm Sentence, told the BBC at the time of the murder that Longhurst "would still be here if it wasn't for the internet ".

Following Coutts's conviction, Longhurst's mother organised a petition to ban such images. It was signed by 50,000 people.

But pressure group Backlash, which includes the Libertarian Alliance, the Spanner Trust, the Sexual Freedom Coalition, Feminists Against Censorship, Ofwatch and Unfettered, has condemned the legislation and called for its withdrawal.

"Much has been made of the 50,000 who signed the petition organised by [Labour MP] Martin Salter and the Jane Longhurst Trust," said the group in a statement.

"But the wording of the petition invites signatories to oppose 'extreme internet sites promoting violence against women in the name of sexual gratification'.

"Anyone would object to material 'promoting' violence against women, but the scope of the legislation is much wider than this. It criminalises material featuring consenting adults engaging in staged or controlled fantasies."

Backlash warned that the proposed legislation would hit BDSM groups, Goths and many horror or thriller films that "convey a realistic impression of fear, violence and harm".

"No-one is stopping people doing weird stuff to each other but they are strongly advised not to put it on the internet," said Salter, who has been involved in writing the legislation. "It is all too easy for this stuff to trigger an unbalanced mind."

But this assertion has been disputed by scientists, who claim that it is just another example of a moral panic.

"The current fears around the possible impact of 'violent pornography' on the internet seem very similar to previous 'moral panics' from penny dreadfuls in Victorian times, to horror comics in the 1950s, to video nasties in the 1980s," said Dr Megan Barker, senior lecturer in psychology at London's South Bank University.

"Time and time again research has challenged the simple cause-effect relationship between exposure to such media and violent behaviour.

"But it is an easy scapegoat in a society which does not want to look at the more complex and insidious reasons for crime and violence, for example issues around poverty, class and the kinds of gender roles that are valued."

Tags:

Further reading

EU debates banning violent games

Spending the day thinking of the children   More...

Virginia shootings rekindle violent gaming debate

Critics quick to blame 32 deaths on Cho Seung Hui's gaming habits   More...

US teen violence study exonerates video games

Shoot 'em ups 'not to blame', says American Sociological Association   More...

$4,000 phone bill for porn leads to suicide

Case may bring mobile curfew for teens in South Korea   More...

Related articles

Do you agree?

Advertisement

Job of the week

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Hiring now on ComputingCareers:

Related IT jobs

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Advertisement

Watch

16 May 2008

2.97 MBXP on OLPC, broken dreams and Yahoo fights back More...

15 May 2008

3.28 MBDark fibre, mobile TV and solar power More...

14 May 2008

2.66 MBOnline inequality, mobile thumbprints and corporate raids More...

Poll

HOME WORKING

HOME WORKING

Do you let any or all of your employees work from home?

Previous poll results

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Spotlight

OLPC

OLPC to ship with Windows XP

Microsoft teams up with One Laptop per Child project   More...

The Sims

The Sims goes flat-pack with Ikea

Virtual world gets Swedish wood   More...

Advertisement

Microsoft-Yahoo

Yahoo board fights back at Icahn

Investor accused of 'significant misunderstanding' in Microsoft saga   More...

MySpace

Woman charged over MySpace suicide

Lori Drew indicted on federal charges   More...

Advertisement