Web search
Google, Yahoo, MSN and Ask deliver very different results from the same search term

Study finds huge difference in search results

Overlap in first-page results from the big four is less than one per cent

Written by Andrew Charlesworth

New research has found that different search engines can produce wildly different results.

The overlap in first-page results is less than one per cent across the four major search engines - Google, Yahoo, MSN and Ask - because they use different algorithms to rank pages. 

The study was commissioned by metadata firm WebFetch and carried out by researchers at the Queensland University of Technology and Pennsylvania State University

The findings also suggest that the difference between the results the search engines throw up has increased over the past two years.

Only 0.6 per cent of 776,435 first-page search results were the same across the top four search engines.

The research expanded on a similar overlap study conducted in 2005 and found that the major engines produce even fewer of the same results today than they did just two years ago, simply because the web is constantly expanding.

"People who depend on just one engine are choosing to limit their search potential," said Dominic Trigg, vice president of search and directories at InfoSpace, the company behind WebFetch. 

"There may be hundreds of relevant hits omitted from a results list, simply because of a particular search algorithm that your chosen search engine uses."

WebFetch is a metadata company, and Trigg claims that the only way to ensure rounded search results is to use a meta search engine which aggregates searches from other search engines and specialist sites like Blinkx and Kelkoo.

Tags:

Further reading

Search engines cleared of bias favouring big sites

There is no 'Googlearchy'   More...

Users exposed to millions of risky searches

Study claims four per cent of all results lead to malware   More...

Search engine mashup to 'tame' the web

Chinese computer scientists develop bot to trawl search engines   More...

Microsoft aims to boost search engine accuracy

Redmond's research division unveils new technology   More...

Related articles

Internet users too trusting of search engine results

Top results are not always the best   More...

Developers hunt for 'Satan' in software code

Code search tool reveals what lies within   More...

Rambus under fire for EU 'patent ambush'

European Commission gets tough with chip firm   More...

Yahoo and Apple top customer ratings

Google loses top service spot   More...

Do you agree?

Advertisement

Job of the week

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Hiring now on ComputingCareers:

Related IT jobs

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Advertisement

Watch

08 Jul 2008

3.67 MBSafe browsing, voice recognition and cyber-criminals More...

07 Jul 2008

2.76 MBLaptops on holiday, gaming in Vietnam and 'unbreakable' encryption More...

04 Jul 2008

5.51 MBPodcast Special: Views from the Valley More...

Poll

EUROPEAN E-COMMERCE

EUROPEAN E-COMMERCE

Are you happy making an online purchase from another European country?

Previous poll results

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Spotlight

Firefox

Firefox users shown to be safer

Internet Explorer users the worst of the bunch   More...

Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers

Icann downplays recent site hacks

Redirects were 'limited', says organisation   More...

Advertisement

DNA

Boffins build artificial DNA

Could be used in the ultimate computer   More...

Microsoft

Microsoft outlines appeal against EU fine

Two sides back in court   More...

Advertisement