Comcast caught blocking BitTorrent traffic

Vendor abandons net neutrality

Written by Tom Sanders in California

US cable provider Comcast is interfering with BitTorrent file transfer traffic for its broadband subscribers.

A test by Associated Press demonstrated that the provider prevented users from sharing files on the file sharing network. The firm achieves this by sending a message to the computer requesting the file which instructs it to stop communicating.

Even though it is common knowledge that BitTorrent is used for downloading copyrighted materials on a massive scale, the network also has plenty of legitimate applications. Several Linux distributions including Ubuntu, for instance, rely on the network to dispense their software. In the Associated Press test, the agency attempted to share and download a copy of the King James Bible, which is in the public domain.

Comcast is the second largest internet provider in the US. The firm previously denied that it blocked or discriminated against BitTorrent traffic.

Comcast claims that the upload-blocking measure is intended to ensure network uptime for all users. The video and audio files that are up- and downloaded through the file sharing network take up the vast majority of all network traffic, and could degrade network speeds for other users. Comcast's defence, however, sparked some questions, given that the tested file measured only a few megabytes.

Instead, it rekindled the debate about net neutrality, which revolves around the question of whether a provider should be allowed to arbitrarily block content. Although vendors hold the legal reign over their own networks, critics caution that their commercial interests could interfere with free speech or open competition.

Tags:

Further reading

Related articles

Comcast admits to throttling BitTorrent

Cable firm explains traffic management policy in FCC filing   More...

Industry heavyweights ride out for net neutrality

Cerf and Schneier fight for open access   More...

Work-time surfers face closer scrutiny

Wan appliance exposes IM, gaming and downloading   More...

Google Video blasted over piracy claims

Copyright watchdog files report alleging violations on Google Video   More...

Do you agree?

Advertisement

Job of the week

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Hiring now on ComputingCareers:

Related IT jobs

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Advertisement

Watch

09 May 2008

2.51 MBWiMax muddle, Google tactics and asteroid bunkum More...

08 May 2008

3.26 MBBroadband Anywhere, phone-free transport and Web 3.0 More...

07 May 2008

3.19 MBUK success, a paucity of IT women and robot wars More...

Poll

DATA ENCRYPTION

DATA ENCRYPTION

Should encryption be mandatory for all personal data held by companies and governments?

Previous poll results

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Spotlight

Ofcom

Ofcom outlines future wireless vision

Wi-Fi healthcare and intelligent car brakes in the pipeline   More...

HP

HP Labs opens doors to academia

Innovation Research Program invites proposals related to current research   More...

Advertisement

Asteroid

Nasa plans manned mission to asteroid

Bruce Willis thankfully not going   More...

MySpace

MySpace offers opt-in data sharing

Deals signed with Photobucket, Twitter, eBay and Yahoo   More...

Advertisement