Kaspersky
Kaspersky has received strong support in its court battle with Zango

Zango v. Kaspersky battle heats up

Sides square off in adware-blocking case

Written by Shaun Nichols in California

Zango ignores the goal most relevant here, which is 'to encourage the development of technologies which maximise user control over what information is received'

Court filing 

Security vendors have pledged support for antivirus firm Kaspersky in its US district court battle against software firm Zango.

The two companies are in court to decide whether Kaspersky is acting illegally in blocking Zango's ad-displaying software.

Zango offers access to multimedia files, games and utilities in exchange for agreeing to install adware.

The vendor argues that its products should not be considered adware because users are clearly informed about the ad-serving software before installing, and that all users agree to a Zango end user license agreement.

Zango was fined by the Federal Trade Commission in 2006 for using deceptive practices to spread its software.

The company has since changed its distribution policies and affiliate programme, and now claims to be completely in line with the requirements of the settlement.

However, critics still argue that the agreements are deceptively formatted and that Zango and its affiliates do not clearly define the software's function.

Other critics contend that users would not agree to install Zango if they were informed about the full results of an install.

Security vendors including McAfee and Sunbelt Software, as well as the Electronic Frontier Foundation, filed an Amicus Brief on Monday in support of Kaspersky.

The group claims in the filing that Kaspersky is protected from legal action by Section 230 of the Telecommunications Act 1996, which shields service providers and companies which filter indecent or unwanted content.

"When Congress enacted Section 230, it articulated and pursued three distinct legislative goals," reads the filing.

"In its brief, appellant Zango only emphasises one of the three goals, and Zango ignores the goal most relevant here, which is 'to encourage the development of technologies which maximise user control over what information is received'."

A spokesperson for Zango declined to comment on the filing, but directed vnunet.com to an earlier Amicus Brief filed in support of the company by the National Business Coalition on E-commerce & Privacy.

This filing argues that extending Section 230 protection to Kaspersky would set a dangerous precedent and put too much power in the hands of security vendors.

"It will effectively empower security software purveyors as the ultimate arbiters of 'objectionable' content on the internet," read the filing.

"This will endanger many legitimate applications, programs, content and online platforms."

Further reading

Facebook hit by adware attack

'Secret Crush' proves anything but   More...

Sex network settles in porno pop-up flap

Adult Friend Finder bows to FTC   More...

FTC shuts down adware ring

ERG Ventures agrees to pay $330,000 over covert Media Motor installations   More...

Zango withdraws PC Tools complaint

Lots of bark but no bite   More...

Related articles

Sex network settles in porno pop-up flap

Adult Friend Finder bows to FTC   More...

Web firms fear legal action over user comments

Big guns backing Roommates.com   More...

Zango withdraws PC Tools complaint

Lots of bark but no bite   More...

FTC shuts down adware ring

ERG Ventures agrees to pay $330,000 over covert Media Motor installations   More...

Do you agree?

Advertisement

Job of the week

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Hiring now on ComputingCareers:

Related IT jobs

Search thousands of IT jobs :

Search thousands of IT jobs:

Advanced search

Advertisement

Watch

13 May 2008

3.06 MBBloody students, goodbye to Dixons and hacking excuses More...

BusinessGreen.com podcast logo

13 May 2008

1.82 MBEco-Entrepreneur introduction More...

12 May 2008

2.4 MBMicrosoft's battles, data breach fines and website rip-offs More...

Poll

DATA ENCRYPTION

DATA ENCRYPTION

Should encryption be mandatory for all personal data held by companies and governments?

Previous poll results

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Enter email address to edit your newsletter preferences

Spotlight

BlackBerry Bold

RIM unveils slimmed-down BlackBerry Bold

New handset due this summer   More...

BlackBerry Bold

BlackBerry Bold takes on 3G iPhone

New models go head-to-head, says analyst   More...

Advertisement

HP

HP 'in talks' to buy EDS

Company offering upwards of $12bn   More...

Virgin Media

Virgin prepares 50Mbps launch in 2008

Successful trial clears network for higher speeds   More...

Advertisement